What are the proper procedures for evicting a tenant without a lease?
Back
You can evict your tenant without a lease in cases where you decide to:
- Reclaim the unit for certain personal reasons
- Carry out major renovations that will make the apartment uninhabitable during the work period
- Subdivide the unit, demolish it, enlarge it, or change its use
The specific rules of the Tribunal administratif du logement (TAL) and the Civil Code of Quebec (C.c.Q.) apply even if your tenant does not have a written lease.
According to Article 1378 of the C.c.Q., “A contract is an agreement of wills by which one or several persons obligate themselves to one or several others to perform a prestation.” Additionally, Article 1385 of the C.c.Q. states that “A contract is formed by the mere exchange of consents between persons having the capacity to contract, unless the law requires, in addition, the observance of a particular form as a necessary condition of its formation, or unless the parties subject the formation of the contract to a solemn form.”
Thus, these legal articles demonstrate that you have a valid contract even if your tenant has not signed a lease. It is therefore considered a verbal lease under Article 1895 of the C.c.Q., meaning that legal conditions related to the eviction of a tenant must be respected.
Exceptions are also provided by the law, so make sure to verify if you have the right to evict your tenant.
After reading this article, you will have all the tools at hand to proceed with the eviction of your tenant in a compliant manner, respecting both parties to the contract.
Legal Advice: With lease forms now widely accessible, it is strongly recommended to have a written lease agreement between the landlord and the tenant. Appearing before the Tribunal administratif du logement often involves matters of evidence and knowledge of each party’s rights. Written proof will always carry more weight than verbal agreements. Additionally, the mandatory lease forms outline the respective rights of both landlord and tenant on the back. Knowing these rights can prevent future complications.
Distinguishing Verbal Leases from Fixed-Term Leases
From the outset, it is important to know that a verbal lease creates the same rights and obligations as a written lease. Therefore, you must comply with the provisions set out in the law regarding:
- Renewal notices
- Urgent and necessary repairs
- Access to the property
- The condition of the property and enjoyment of the premises
Since a verbal lease is generally considered an indefinite-term lease, you must follow the legal rules for this type of lease. For example, the notice period for renewal must be 1 to 2 months before the end of the lease.
A verbal lease can also be terminated by the tenant under certain conditions permitted by law:
- If the landlord neglects their obligations
- In cases of domestic or sexual violence
- If the tenant needs to leave the property due to special needs
The lease must be respected until its end, except in these legally enumerated exceptions or with the landlord’s agreement.
Regardless of whether it is a fixed-term or verbal lease, the right to maintain the premises applies. This principle means that, except in legally listed exceptions, a tenant can stay in the property as long as they wish.
This is why you cannot evict your tenant without reason, even if they do not have a written lease. Certain conditions must be met to evict a tenant without a written lease.
However, nothing prevents you from offering your tenant a sum of money to waive their right to remain in the premises, subject to legal exclusions. Your tenant can decide whether to accept or reject this proposal.
Reclaiming the Property
As long as your tenant complies with the conditions of their verbal lease, they may stay in the apartment. However, if you wish to reclaim your property, specific circumstances allow you to do so lawfully, such as:
- To live in the property yourself
- To house your children or parents
- To house your separated or divorced spouse for whom you remain the primary support
- To house any other relative or in-law for whom you are the primary support
An official notice must be sent 6 months before the set date for reclaiming the property. A model of this notice is offered by the Tribunal administratif du logement, making it easy and simple to draft the document.
Your tenant has one month to respond. If they don’t, it is assumed that they refuse to leave. The tenant can also refuse immediately upon receiving the notice. In that case, try to negotiate with them to offer favorable departure conditions.
You might offer compensation for moving expenses or their first month’s rent. While not legally required, this could help end your relationship amicably with the tenant. The tenant could also request compensation through the Tribunal administratif du logement.
If your tenant refuses to discuss or leave, you will have to proceed with legal steps at the Tribunal administratif du logement to prove that your reclaim request is lawful and not a pretext for other purposes.
Legal Advice: An amicable agreement is the simplest solution to avoid appearing before the Tribunal administratif du logement. Even if your reclaim is fully compliant, you will still bear the legal costs and need to prove your reclaim intent. Note that, unlike eviction, a three-month rent indemnity is not required for a reclaim. In negotiations, you should offer to cover reasonable moving costs and other related expenses.
Evicting a Tenant without a Written Lease
To temporarily or permanently evict a tenant without a written lease, certain specific conditions listed in the law must be met. As a landlord, you may:
- Evict your tenant if you intend to subdivide, demolish, enlarge, or change the use of the property.
- Evict your tenant for major renovations that will make the property uninhabitable during the work period.
An official notice is also required in eviction situations and must be sent 6 months before the planned work date. However, if no evacuation is needed and the work period is under a week, a 10-day notice is sufficient.
Depending on the eviction reason, templates are available on the Tribunal administratif du logement’s website to properly draft your notice:
- Repair or major improvement notice
- Eviction notice for subdivision, substantial enlargement, or change of use
The notice must include:
- The evacuation period
- The compensation amount offered
- The reason for the eviction
- The eviction date
The proposed compensation is payable on the evacuation date and covers moving expenses, temporary rent, etc. If the eviction is permanent, the tenant may receive three months’ rent as indemnity and reasonable moving expenses.
Your tenant has one month to respond. If they do not respond, they are assumed to consent to leaving.
What Happens If the Tenant Refuses to Leave?
If the tenant refuses to leave after receiving an eviction notice, they must try to negotiate with you or appeal to the Tribunal administratif du logement. In court, you must prove the validity of your eviction reason.
Legal Advice: To prove a substantial enlargement or subdivision, it is strongly recommended to have a complete project plan to present to the Tribunal administratif du logement, including feasibility studies, financial planning, permit acquisition, and sometimes client search efforts.
Lease Termination
It’s important to differentiate between eviction and lease termination. Article 1863 of the Civil Code of Quebec specifies that if one party’s failure to meet an obligation causes significant harm to the other party, the harmed party can request lease termination.
Article 1971 C.c.Q. also notes that a landlord can obtain lease termination if the tenant is over three weeks late on rent or frequently delays payment, resulting in serious harm to the landlord.
Grounds for Terminating a Verbal Lease
A verbal lease can be terminated if the tenant:
- Fails to pay rent on the agreed date
- Commits illegal acts within the property
- Causes damage to the property
- Disturbs other tenants’ peace
- Endangers others’ safety
- Renders the property unsanitary
- Changes the property’s form or use
- Overcrowds the property with occupants
- Sublets or assigns the property without the landlord’s consent
A formal notice can then be sent to the tenant requesting them to comply with their obligations within a specified period. An agreement can subsequently be reached between you and your tenant. If you receive no response, it is possible to file a procedure with the Tribunal administratif du logement. Only a judgment from this authority can compel the tenant to leave the premises based on one of the aforementioned reasons.
As for the eviction of the tenant, it is a completely distinct procedure that applies in the specific cases mentioned in the previous section. Therefore, an eviction is not handled in the same way as a lease termination.
What is the eviction of an unauthorized occupant?
An unauthorized occupant is a person who occupies a dwelling without the landlord’s permission. This can occur when a tenant decides not to leave the property despite receiving a notice of departure or non-renewal of the lease. This situation can also happen during property reclamation or tenant eviction when the tenant changes their mind and refuses to vacate.
The most common case is when a tenant agrees to a verbal lease end date but chooses to stay in the property. For example, you might have taken steps to reclaim your property to house an aging parent. Everything was done according to regulations, and your tenant agreed to abide by your decision. You even offered them a significant compensation! However, they change their mind at the last minute and become an unauthorized occupant.
So, what can you do to make your tenant without a lease leave?
Article 1889 of the Civil Code of Quebec (C.c.Q.) states that “the lessor of an immovable may obtain the expulsion of the lessee who continues to occupy the leased premises after the end of the lease or after the date agreed during the lease for the surrender of the premises.”
The only method to evict an unauthorized occupant is to file a legal action with the Tribunal administratif du logement. The eviction is then carried out by a bailiff, as authorized by the court, making it necessary to obtain a judgment.
Many such requests have been filed with the Tribunal administratif du logement over the years, with a record set from 2018 to 2019, when more than 400 judgments were rendered on this issue.
Verbal proof before the Tribunal administratif du logement
No matter the reason you need to appear in court, proof of the verbal lease will be required. Since there are no written records, the credibility of testimonies from both tenant and landlord will serve as evidence. The judge will assess these based on established jurisprudence principles. Additionally, it is important to send a written notice to the tenant within 10 days following the conclusion of the lease, indicating your name and address, the rent amount, and the rented property address as stipulated in Article 1895 C.c.Q., along with a copy of Annex 7 of the mandatory lease forms regulation from the Tribunal administratif du logement.
A key decision concerning verbal leases states:
“The probative value of testimonial evidence depends on the credibility of each witness and the quality of their testimony, considering the manner of testifying and the content of the responses, elements that the tribunal considers to render a judgment according to the weight of the evidence.”
Thus, it is up to the judge to validate the verbal agreement made between you and your tenant.
This first step must be performed during a hearing at the Tribunal administratif du logement. It is your responsibility to clearly explain the content of the verbal lease and the terms agreed upon with your tenant.
However, written agreements remain the best form of evidence. Written lease terms are much easier to prove than verbal leases. It is advisable to use written agreements to facilitate the relationship with your tenant. For example, if you wish to reclaim the property for your daughter and the tenant agrees, make sure to clearly document all the agreement terms. This significantly simplifies the proof process in court if your tenant becomes an unauthorized occupant.
Restrictions on evicting a tenant without a lease
In 2016, the enactment of the law amending the Civil Code to protect senior tenants’ rights altered the conditions for reclaiming property and evicting a tenant as indicated in the Civil Code of Quebec. These new provisions significantly protect seniors, aiming to reduce discrimination against older tenants.
They also closely regulate the rules under which a landlord can evict a tenant aged 70 or older. Eviction or property reclamation is not possible if your tenant or their spouse:
- Is aged 70 or older
- Has lived in the property for 10 years or more
- Has an annual income qualifying them for low-rent housing (HLM).
If your tenant or their spouse meets all these criteria, you cannot proceed with their eviction or reclaim the property.
However, certain exceptions are possible, such as when you:
- Are yourself aged 70 or older and wish to reclaim the property for personal residence
- Wish to reclaim the property for a senior family member, ex-spouse, parent, or ally
- Are an owner-occupant aged 70 or older wishing to house a family member, ex-spouse, parent, or ally under 70 in the same building.
In such specific situations, you may evict your tenant even if they or their spouse are over 70. Property reclamation is also possible under these circumstances.
Article 1959.1 C.c.Q. details these provisions, ensuring better protection for senior tenants in Quebec.
Can a tenant without a written lease be forced to leave at the end of their lease due to a Tribunal administratif du logement decision?
A tenant without a written lease must comply with the Tribunal administratif du logement’s judgment. They can be compelled to leave at the lease’s end or as designated by the Tribunal.
Due to the pandemic, specific measures were implemented by the government to protect public health. In March 2020, a ministerial order suspended the effects of any Tribunal administratif du logement decision authorizing property reclamation or tenant eviction.
This ministerial order was valid until July 6, 2020, for decisions made before March 1, 2020. Its validity was extended to July 20, 2020, for decisions rendered since March 1, 2020.
Furthermore, this new measure required exceptional circumstances to justify implementing a court decision regarding eviction or property reclamation.
For instance, in the case of Bond v. Ponce, the court ruled that although the tenant disturbed other tenants’ peaceful enjoyment, this did not constitute an exceptional circumstance justifying lease termination.
However, since June 1, 2020, the Tribunal administratif du logement has resumed hearing all types of requests, including:
- Eviction
- Property reclamation
- Lease termination
Note that an eviction request for an unauthorized occupant is considered urgent.
Remember, even if your tenant has not signed a lease, they have the same rights as a tenant with a written lease. They are also subject to the same lease obligations.
If they fail to meet these obligations, you can request the lease termination. A court judgment will then allow you to evict the tenant without a written lease.
You now have all the essential information to properly evict a tenant without a lease. Whether your tenants have verbal or written leases, always rely on the law. Treat verbal leases no differently and be fully aware of your obligations and rights. This way, you will be able to evict your tenant without a lease in compliance with current legal provisions.
